You are in a complicated situation and you have to keep a secret, but your parents or maybe your best friend ask(s) you what is the secret about. Would you lie to them or tell them the true? And explain why?
I think we should keep the secret because if this secret come from a person and this person told us not repeat it and you repeat it, this person will be angry at you.
I think it is necessary to keep these secrets but sometimes it is necessary to say even if one hurts the people because by keeping these secrets one can harm other people
Hello ! If you have secret about something not very dangerous or something like that, I think you can lie without any risks for you or your friend. Of course if this secret can destroy a life, upset very important person for you or your friends, its very important to talk and try to take good part of this situation (I know this situation, you can trust me). Of course, you'll maybe make cry people, they'll hate you, but if they love you, or if they don't want to lose you,they will forgive you and be more confident than before. My grand-father who was a long career soldier in french army, told me this motto two months before dying : "A fault confessed is half redressed". Since this day, I always try to stop lying to my friend and my family, and I started to live in this path.
I'm sorry if there's some/a lot of misatkes, don't forgot to correct me if there is.
It really depends on what the secret is about. I mean if it's something that I can keep for myself, of course I will not tell anyone about it. However, if somebody's life is in danger, I will try to do my best to help the person concerned for my part, first. Then, whether it is too hard to support, I will carefully bring somebody up to date. Nevertheless, I've never been confronted to such a huge problem so, I cannot tell what I would do in this case.
In my opinion, it depends. If it's a little secret like for example : "i didn't do my homework" and if i tell to my parents that I did it although it's not true, I will not tell them the truth but if the secret that I keep put my life in danger, I will tell to my parents first and maybe some friends that I trust the most but I think that you have to be careful to whom you trust.
"If it's a secret about not doing my homework, and I told my parents that I had done it although it wasn't true, I wouldn't tell them the truth....if I were in danger.... I would tell my parents...some friends whom....careful because you can't trust everyone" To tell someone... sans "to"
Hello, to be honnest, I would not tell this secret to my parents if it isn't a serious problem but if the secret was a really serious thing, of course I would tell them. And for my friends, I can tell them the secret but probably not to all my friends, only with the good friends that I know since a long time and I trust them...
And Hadil you should have wrote "the truth" instead of "the true"
On this subject, I would lie to my friends because there are no friends in life, if one day I would argue with them, they would be able to unveil the secret, while my parents I could tell them the secret But it depends on the secret because they could take it wrong.
Hello, i think the best solution is to keep his secret if it's not serious and if it's not about us. If it's a friend who told us an secret I think it must keep this secret but it's about us for example an people who is harassed must tell her or his parents.
Hi everyone! In my opinion, I think that if I had to keep a secret, I will not talk about it with my friends even if it's my best friend because I think that it's not correct to betray a promise, myself I wouldn't have liked to be tell my secret. Nevertheless, if it would be a very serious problem, I guess, I will talk about it with my parents because they are responsible and trusted adults and they will try to find a solution that which will allow me to help my friend.
Hello everybody ! A secret is a proof of trust , we can disclose this secret in differents situation. If one of my friends tell me a important problem , and if she/he is in danger i think i will tel his /her secret to a adult.But if his/her problem don't put her / his in danger I would never tell his /her secret to anyone. Melissa Boudraa 205
To my mind, if I was in complicated situation, I was looking for a solution before talking to anyone. However, acting alone is not a solution… Moreover if the person asks me to keep it for me and this person is in predicament, I would say to someone especially my parents, even if this secret betrayed that person, I wouldn’t let the situation happens. Although, keep a secret can be done to help people to confess and also to help him/her when there are into trouble. So, yes I would break secret for help this person.
I think that best would be, not to keep his secrets, to keep them could have bad consequences.
ReplyDeleteBankolé Abyss 203
I think we should keep the secret because if this secret come from a person and this person told us not repeat it and you repeat it, this person will be angry at you.
ReplyDeleteMathieu Marlet
I think it is necessary to keep these secrets but sometimes it is necessary to say even if one hurts the people because by keeping these secrets one can harm other people
ReplyDeleteI think it's better to say if we have a problem with a friend or a member of his family because in this case we can have support.
ReplyDeleteThomas Muro
For me, when you keep a secret, it's important to respect your promess. Lying to keep a secret doesn't matter.
ReplyDeleteif i have a secret from a friend i will not tell anybody because he trust in me. But if he is in danger, i will tell this secret to peaple i trust in
ReplyDeletesorry i think you meant "people" instead of "peaple"
DeleteHello ! If you have secret about something not very dangerous or something like that, I think you can lie without any risks for you or your friend. Of course if this secret can destroy a life, upset very important person for you or your friends, its very important to talk and try to take good part of this situation (I know this situation, you can trust me). Of course, you'll maybe make cry people, they'll hate you, but if they love you, or if they don't want to lose you,they will forgive you and be more confident than before. My grand-father who was a long career soldier in french army, told me this motto two months before dying : "A fault confessed is half redressed". Since this day, I always try to stop lying to my friend and my family, and I started to live in this path.
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry if there's some/a lot of misatkes, don't forgot to correct me if there is.
Sorry I think you meant "mistakes" instead of "misatkes"
DeleteIt really depends on what the secret is about.
ReplyDeleteI mean if it's something that I can keep for myself, of course I will not tell anyone about it.
However, if somebody's life is in danger, I will try to do my best to help the person concerned for my part, first.
Then, whether it is too hard to support, I will carefully bring somebody up to date. Nevertheless, I've never been confronted to such a huge problem so, I cannot tell what I would do in this case.
MORONI Marie 1S4
In my opinion, if we are given a secret it is to keep it, otherwise we lose the trust of his friend.
ReplyDeletePaul Latorré 2°4
In my opinion, it depends. If it's a little secret like for example : "i didn't do my homework" and if i tell to my parents that I did it although it's not true, I will not tell them the truth but if the secret that I keep put my life in danger, I will tell to my parents first and maybe some friends that I trust the most but I think that you have to be careful to whom you trust.
ReplyDeleteROMAN Lisa 2°3
"If it's a secret about not doing my homework, and I told my parents that I had done it although it wasn't true, I wouldn't tell them the truth....if I were in danger.... I would tell my parents...some friends whom....careful because you can't trust everyone" To tell someone... sans "to"
ReplyDeleteHello, to be honnest, I would not tell this secret to my parents if it isn't a serious problem but if the secret was a really serious thing, of course I would tell them. And for my friends, I can tell them the secret but probably not to all my friends, only with the good friends that I know since a long time and I trust them...
ReplyDeleteAnd Hadil you should have wrote "the truth" instead of "the true"
LUCAS SEIDITA 2°3
On this subject, I would lie to my friends because there are no friends in life, if one day I would argue with them, they would be able to unveil the secret, while my parents I could tell them the secret But it depends on the secret because they could take it wrong.
ReplyDeleteHello,
ReplyDeletei think the best solution is to keep his secret if it's not serious and if it's not about us.
If it's a friend who told us an secret I think it must keep this secret but it's about us for example an people who is harassed must tell her or his parents.
Hi everyone!
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, I think that if I had to keep a secret, I will not talk about it with my friends even if it's my best friend because I think that it's not correct to betray a promise, myself I wouldn't have liked to be tell my secret. Nevertheless, if it would be a very serious problem, I guess, I will talk about it with my parents because they are responsible and trusted adults and they will try to find a solution that which will allow me to help my friend.
Hello everybody ! A secret is a proof of trust , we can disclose this secret in differents situation. If one of my friends tell me a important problem , and if she/he is in danger i think i will tel his /her secret to a adult.But if his/her problem don't put her / his in danger I would never tell his /her secret to anyone. Melissa Boudraa 205
ReplyDeleteSorry i made some mistakes :different solutions , will tell , doesn't
DeleteTo my mind, if I was in complicated situation, I was looking for a solution before talking to anyone.
ReplyDeleteHowever, acting alone is not a solution… Moreover if the person asks me to keep it for me and this person is in predicament, I would say to someone especially my parents, even if this secret betrayed that person, I wouldn’t let the situation happens. Although, keep a secret can be done to help people to confess and also to help him/her when there are into trouble. So, yes I would break secret for help this person.